Shopify Discounts: Free Gifts vs Money Off — What Converts Best?
What if giving customers a free gift could increase your Shopify store's average order value instead of relying on another discount?
In this episode of Winning With Shopify, Nick Truman sits down with Charlie Tyler to break down insights from **10 million Shopify customer journeys** and reveal how gifting, discounts, and tiered rewards can influence customer spending.
They discuss why orders with gifts showed approximately a **30% increase in average order value**, how to set the right free-gift threshold, why mystery and digital gifts can work, and how brands can avoid discount fatigue.
You'll also learn:
• Free gifts vs traditional discount codes
• How to use tiered gifting to increase AOV
• Why your gift should sit just above your normal AOV
• Common gifting mistakes that can increase shipping costs
• How luxury brands can use gifts without devaluing their products
• Why constant discounts can hurt your brand
• Smarter Black Friday & Cyber Monday strategies
• How progressive discounts create urgency
• What Shopify data you should actually monitor
• How Easy Gift and Get Sale can automate these strategies
Whether you're preparing for BFCM or simply looking for a smarter way to increase Shopify revenue, this episode is packed with practical strategies you can test on your store.
TIMESTAMPS:
00:00 – Free Gifts vs Discounts
03:45 – How Free Gifts Can Increase AOV by 30%
05:05 – Finding the Right Free Gift Threshold
06:35 – What Gifts Should You Offer Customers?
10:10 – Mystery Gifts & Digital Gifts
15:10 – Free Gifts vs Traditional Discounts
20:10 – Automating Shopify Discounts & Offers
25:20 – Tiered Gifting to Increase Customer Spend
28:10 – Black Friday Without Devaluing Your Brand
39:35 – Smarter Discount Strategies for Shopify
Subscribe to Winning With Shopify for more Shopify growth, ecommerce marketing, SEO, conversion, and retention strategies.
Winning with Shopify listeners get an extended 30 day free trial on any of the three. Details at 506.io/wws, code WWS
Omnisend - 30% off paid plans for three months with code WINNINGWITHOMNISEND.
Ships-A-Lot - Improve fulfilment costs, shipping margins and customer experience.
https://info.shipsalot.com/winning-with-shopify
Yoast - 15% off Shopify and WordPress with code WWS15.
https://yoast.com/product/yoast-seo-shopify/
Inventory Planner - Free seven-day inventory bootcamp.
https://info.brightpearl.com/winning-with-shopify-holiday-planning-bootcamp
Related Episodes
Rank + Convert: Shopify SEO Secrets with Yoast
SEO isn’t a “set and forget” task, and AI content doesn’t magically fix that. In this episode, Nick sits down with Sid from Yoast (Senior Customer Success Manager & Merchant Insights Advisor) to break down what’s really moving the needle for Shopify SEO right now - from technical foundations to content that actually converts. You’ll learn:
Listen or Watch →
Double Your Shopify Revenue In 5 Simple Steps
With having worked with almost 2000 brands throughout his career, Nick shares the steps that are helping brands double their Shopify revenue right now! In this episode we explore why customers buy your products and how to harness the power of customer data to boost your sales. Discover the truth about increasing sales and learn actionable strategies to elevate your Shopify store's average order value. Dive into the world of AI product recommendations and see how leveraging influencer marketing
Listen or Watch →
How To Build A Brand Customers Never Leave | Winning with Shopify
If you're trying to grow a Shopify store, focusing only on products and ads isn't enough. In this episode of the Winning With Shopify Podcast, Nick Trueman sits down with marketing leader Nadine to discuss what separates successful DTC brands from ordinary ecommerce stores. You'll learn why brand matters more than ever, how AI is changing product discovery, why retention beats acquisition, how subscriptions increase lifetime value, and why founders should stop racing to the bottom on price.
Listen or Watch →