The Black Friday Discount Trap Shopify Brands Must Avoid
Thinking about running 20% off your Shopify store this Black Friday? The real cost to your business could be much bigger than 20%.
In this episode of Winning With Shopify, Nick breaks down the maths behind Black Friday discounts, ecommerce profit margins, ROAS and customer acquisition to show why seemingly harmless discounts can dramatically reduce profitability.
Using a simple example, a $100 product with a $50 cost has a $50 gross profit. Apply a 20% Black Friday discount and the selling price drops to $80—but the product still costs $50. Gross profit therefore falls to $30, meaning the 20% discount has actually removed 40% of the original gross profit.
And advertising makes the economics even more important.
Nick demonstrates what happens when Google or Meta Ads, ROAS, lower average order value and increased order volume are added to the calculation—and why a store can generate impressive Black Friday revenue while ending the period with significantly less actual profit.
The episode also looks beyond the first purchase. Nick discusses research he reviewed across DTC stores in which only 17% of newly acquired Black Friday/Cyber Monday customers bought again, highlighting why brands should pay close attention to the quality and lifetime value of customers acquired through heavy discounting.
But that doesn't mean Shopify brands should ignore Black Friday.
Nick shares alternatives to blanket discounting, including free gifts, exclusive bundles, extended warranties, loyalty rewards, tiered offers, limited quantities and Black Friday-exclusive products.
Finally, you'll get a practical five-point Black Friday profitability checklist covering margins, ROAS targets, customer lifetime value, product selection and post-Black-Friday retention strategy.
If you're a Shopify store owner, ecommerce founder or marketer planning your Black Friday strategy, use this episode to make sure you're optimizing for profit—not just revenue.
Subscribe to Winning With Shopify for practical Shopify, ecommerce, CRO, SEO, advertising and growth strategies.
Chapters:
00:00 – Why 20% Off Can Destroy Your Profit
02:26 – The Black Friday Profit Maths
05:05 – Adding Google & Meta Ad Costs
07:02 – How Discounts Affect AOV & ROAS
10:11 – How to Protect Profit During Black Friday
12:33 – The Problem With Discount-Acquired Customers
15:12 – Better Alternatives to Heavy Discounts
18:24 – Rewards, Bundles & Tiered Offers
21:20 – 3 Principles for a Profitable Black Friday
22:24 – 5-Point Black Friday Profit Checklist
Want some help with profitably scaling your Google Ads? Reach out to Nick's agency: team@spec.digital
Omnisend - 30% off paid plans for three months with code WINNINGWITHOMNISEND.
Ships-A-Lot - Improve fulfilment costs, shipping margins and customer experience.
https://info.shipsalot.com/winning-with-shopify
Yoast - 15% off Shopify and WordPress with code WWS15.
https://yoast.com/product/yoast-seo-shopify/
Inventory Planner - Free seven-day inventory bootcamp.
https://info.brightpearl.com/winning-with-shopify-holiday-planning-bootcamp
506 - Extended 30-day free trial on any of their three Shopify apps with code WWS
#BlackFriday #Shopify #Ecommerce #EcommerceMarketing #ShopifyTips
Related Episodes
Google Ads for Shopify: Why Your Costs Are Rising and What Still Works
Most Shopify brands use Google Ads to drive sales. The fastest-growing brands use it to build a DTC brand. Google Ads has become one of the most powerful ways for ecommerce brands to find new customers - but many Shopify stores are still optimising for short-term ROAS instead of long-term growth. In this episode, Nick explains why most Shopify brands get Google Ads wrong and how successful DTC brands use paid search, Shopping ads and customer data to build a scalable acquisition engine.
Listen or Watch →
Black Friday Is Broken: How AI Will Change Shopify in 2026
Black Friday is broken. Shopify brands can no longer rely on bigger discounts to win — because AI shopping assistants, personalised recommendations and AI-powered search are changing how customers discover and buy products. In this episode of Winning With Shopify, Nick breaks down how AI is transforming Black Friday, Cyber Monday and ecommerce — and what Shopify brands need to do now to prepare for the future of product discovery. As shoppers increasingly use AI to research, compare and discover
Listen or Watch →
3 ChatGPT Prompts to Prepare Your Shopify Store for Black Friday
Black Friday is changing fast — and AI could help Shopify brands prepare smarter, find revenue leaks, improve automations, and avoid costly Black Friday mistakes. In this episode of Winning With Shopify, Nick Trueman shares 3 AI prompts Shopify store owners can use before Black Friday Cyber Monday (BFCM) to assess their marketing readiness and identify what needs fixing before the biggest ecommerce sales period of the year. You'll learn how to use AI to run a Black Friday readiness check, uncove
Listen or Watch →